Sneak Peak: The Cynefin framework offers analysts a valuable lens through which to view and categorise problems, helping them navigate everything from simple, routine tasks to highly complex or chaotic challenges. Whether dealing with known-knowns, known-unknowns, or unknown-unknowns, this framework empowers analysts to create actionable insights, build stakeholder trust, and respond effectively to uncertainty. By mastering Cynefin, analysts can enhance both their decision-making and the collective success of their teams.

to Understanding the Cynefin Framework for Decision-Making in Analysis

We have seen how our analysis tasks are rapidly becoming complex due to changing business environments. Thus, as analysts, we are frequently tasked with interpreting vast amounts of data to create actionable insights. However, not all problems are created equal—some are straightforward, while others are highly uncertain or complex. The Cynefin framework, developed by Dave Snowden in 1999, is a powerful tool that helps analysts and decision-makers navigate these different types of challenges. This article will provide a detailed understanding of the Cynefin framework, explore its use cases, and guide analysts through the steps to handle known-knowns, known-unknowns, and unknown-unknowns. We’ll also cover its history, strengths, limitations, and how analysts can apply it to develop better insights.

Key Takeaways

• Cynefin framework as a solution to navigate different types of problems.

• The framework categorises challenges into five domains: Clear (Simple), Complicated, Complex, Chaotic, and Aporetic (Confusion).

• Each domain requires a different approach to problem-solving, offering analysts a tailored methodology based on the nature of the problem.

• While the framework offers flexibility and better communication, it has limitations like subjectivity and a steep learning curve for novice analysts.

• Ultimately, the Cynefin framework enhances decision-making by categorising problems and fostering adaptability in managing complex situations.

What is the Cynefin Framework?

The Cynefin (pronounced kuh-nev-in) framework is a sense-making tool that helps organisations categorise problems and make informed decisions. It divides challenges into the following five domains:

1. Clear (Simple) - The problem is well understood, and the solution is evident.

2. Complicated - There is a clear relationship between cause and effect, but expertise is required to find the right solution.

3. Complex - The relationship between cause and effect is only apparent in hindsight, and patterns emerge over time.

4. Chaotic - There is no clear cause-and-effect relationship, and immediate action is required.

5. Aporetic (Confusion) - A state of not yet knowing which domain the problem belongs to.

Each domain requires a different approach, allowing analysts to tailor their methods depending on the nature of the problem. This makes Cynefin particularly valuable for decision-making, problem-solving, and managing uncertainty in teams.

History and Discovery of the Cynefin Framework

The Cynefin framework was created by Dave Snowden, a Welsh researcher and consultant while working at IBM’s Institute for Knowledge Management. He introduced it as a sense-making model to help our organisations better understand complex situations and make decisions in uncertain environments. We often are told about this in business school. The term "Cynefin" is derived from a Welsh word meaning "habitat" or "place of multiple belongings," reflecting the idea that decisions are shaped by the context we inhabit.

Use Cases for Analysts

The Cynefin framework has broad applications in analysis and decision-making. Typically, analysts can use this framework when addressing different problem types, navigating uncertainty, improving stakeholder communication, and creating organisational strategy. Analysts can categorise their tasks into one of the five Cynefin domains, helping them decide which tools and methods to use. The framework helps teams deal with uncertainty, especially when facing complex or chaotic problems, by suggesting actions that suit each situation. When dealing with stakeholders, we can use Cynefin to explain the nature of a problem and why certain solutions may or may not be feasible. Leaders use Cynefin to align their strategies with the complexity of the environment, ensuring that their teams remain agile and responsive to change.

Steps for Analysts to Navigate Known-Knowns, Known-Unknowns, and Unknown-Unknowns

• Known-Knowns (Clear Domain) - These are situations where the problem and solution are both obvious. To handle known-knowns, follow the following steps: (1) Sense -> (2) Categorise -> (3) Respond. Use established best practices or standard procedures. We can easily recognise the problem and implement tried-and-true solutions.

• Known-Unknowns (Complicated Domain) - Here, the problem is understood, but the solution requires expert knowledge. To achieve this, we must follow the following steps: (1) Sense -> (2) Analyse -> (3) Respond. We should rely on expert judgment, models, or advanced techniques to uncover the right solution. Multiple solutions may exist, but determining the best one requires analysis. An example would be complex financial forecasting or strategic market analysis where expertise is key to making the right call.

• Unknown-Unknowns (Complex Domain) - These are situations where neither the problem nor the solution is immediately clear, and outcomes are only visible in hindsight. We can follow the following steps to deal with this: (1) Probe -> (2) Sense -> (3) Respond. Let us remember to run experiments, gather data, and observe patterns. Solutions emerge over time, and flexibility is crucial. This is to familiarise ourselves with situations like launching a new product in an untested market or evaluating long-term business transformation strategies.

• Unforeseen Chaos (Chaotic Domain) - In chaotic situations, immediate action is necessary to prevent further disruption, and there’s no time to identify cause and effect. It is suggested that we follow the following steps to navigate chaotic environments: (1) Act -> (2) Sense -> (3) Respond. We are reminded to take decisive action to stabilise the situation and bring it into a more manageable domain. An example of this is crisis management, such as responding to sudden market shocks or data breaches.

Strengths and Limitations of the Cynefin Framework

The Cynefin Framework offers strengths such as flexibility, adaptability, and improved collaboration. It addresses both simple and complex issues, providing analysts with a structured method for a variety of challenges. This approach allows teams to modify their decision-making based on the specific nature of each problem instead of relying on a universal solution. By categorising issues, the framework fosters better communication within teams and with stakeholders, ensuring a shared understanding of the complexities involved.

However, it has limitations, including subjectivity and a learning curve. Accurately placing problems in the correct domain can entail subjective judgments, risking misclassification. Additionally, novice analysts may require time to grasp the distinctions between complicated and complex problems. Critics argue that the Cynefin framework’s division of problems into distinct categories can sometimes oversimplify real-world issues. Problems may move between domains, and hybrid situations may arise. Additionally, some argue that more objective, quantitative frameworks are better suited for decision-making, particularly in data-heavy environments.

How We as Analysts Can Be Aware of This

To use Cynefin effectively, analysts should: (1) Continuously reassess the problem, (2) Stay flexible, and (3) Emphasise collaboration. Problems can shift from one domain to another as new information emerges. Be open to adapting your methods as the problem evolves, especially when moving from complicated to complex or chaotic situations. Ensure team members understand which domain the problem falls under and adjust their decision-making process accordingly.

In this section of our Newsletter, we aim to highlight the work that all our Being An Analyst members are doing to better the community at large. If you would like to be featured here, kindly send us an email: [email protected]

Free Being An Analyst E-Book Download

You are invited to download a free e-book on Kindle using the below link: https://amzn.to/4eJkyqq
The e-book is available to Buy for free and read on Kindle on these dates
11 -14 October 2024
25 October 2024
All analysts are welcome to have a copy (irrespective of country)

Test Your Product/Services in Mid-Spring Market Day

Career Path Training Measures - Cybersecurity

The GIZ’s Digital Skills for Jobs and Income (DS4JI) project seeks to support Cybersecurity training measures that create employment for a minimum of 100 NEET (Not in Employment, Education, & Training) youth, of which 60% are young women. Companies with a proven track record are encouraged to apply to develop and implement a Cybersecurity training programme, not exceeding 9 months, that meets established employer(s) requirements, develops soft skills, provides mentorship from industry experts and secured job placements in roles that match the training. The programme must include support measures for gender transformation and disability mainstreaming, informed by engagement with employers/industry bodies, to address underrepresentation of women and persons with disabilities in Cybersecurity careers.

Tender documents are available for downloading HERE ➡ https://www.giz.de/en/worldwide/200362.html 

Your proposal must be submitted to [email protected] by 01 November 2024. Please quote reference 83473486 when submitting the documentation. Late submissions will not be accepted.

Get Private Banking Previledges Today

Are you Planning a Newsletter?

Unveiling Personal Mastery: Discovering Accidental Career Growth

I have heard about people with great careers and cannot share with the rest of us how did it happen. This is somehow accidental career growth that they experienced. Remember my other article about how most of us who started in analysis in the 2010s were given roles without much sweat? Yes, being given roles, big titles to feed the ego, and so forth can become addictive. As a result, I waited around waiting for another lucky strike to land on my lap with a bigger salary this time. The reality is that accidental growth seldom repeats as compared to intentional growth. The key is personal mastery and a good enough career strategy.

A career strategy is important to us now as we are in the pursuit of personal mastery and professional success and embracing intentional growth habits. In his book “The 15 Invaluable Laws of Growth,” John C. Maxwell provides a roadmap for personal development, highlighting the contrast between intentional and accidental career growth habits. I found this summary to be interesting and insightful for someone like me who didn’t know that I was hoping for accidental growth. In this article, I aim to assist you and other analysts in understanding the key lessons from Maxwell’s book, particularly focusing on the dangers of accidental growth, its advantages and disadvantages, and its impact on the future… Read More

Bridging Analytics and Development: The Mutual Benefits of Analysts and DevOps Collaboration

The growing demand for rapid, high-quality software development and deployment is impeccably met by DevOps, blending the technical and cultural aspects of both development and IT operations. This synergy has proven invaluable across industries and roles, including for Analysts, who are pivotal in extracting and interpreting data to drive strategic business decisions. In case you haven’t heard of what that is, “DevOps” is a combination of two terms, “Development” and “Operations,” and it refers to a set of practices, principles, and cultural philosophies that promote better collaboration and communication between software development (dev) and IT operations (ops) teams. The primary objective of DevOps is to shorten the system development life cycle and provide continuous delivery with high software quality. This article explores how Analysts can amplify the efficacy of DevOps teams and, conversely, how an understanding of DevOps can enhance the role of an Analyst… Read More

Why Buy ‘Being An Analyst’ Book?

'Being An Analyst' is your essential guide to becoming not just an analyst, but a catalyst for success and a driver of organisational change. Order your copy Today!!

This book is the definitive guide to unlocking the transformative potential of informed decision-making and supercharging your analytical skills. Whether you're a budding analyst or a seasoned pro, this book is your ticket to becoming a catalyst for success and a driving force for change within your organisation.